27 companies, one local agent.

• 

  AAA

  aaa.com(opens in a new tab)

  Offered through the AAA – The Auto Club Group independent agent program.

  File a claim: ask DavidMake a payment: ask David
• 

  Acuity

  acuity.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service & claims

  800-242-7666

  File a claimwith Acuity (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Acuity (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Allstate

  allstate.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims

  800-255-7828

  File a claimwith Allstate (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Allstate (opens in a new tab)
• 

  American Modern Insurance Group

  amig.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service

  855-469-2644

  File a claimwith American Modern Insurance Group (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith American Modern Insurance Group (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Auto-Owners Insurance

  auto-owners.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims

  888-252-4626

  File a claimwith Auto-Owners Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Auto-Owners Insurance (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Badger Mutual Insurance

  badgermutual.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service

  800-837-7833

  File a claimwith Badger Mutual Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Badger Mutual Insurance (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Berkshire Hathaway GUARD

  guard.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims

  888-639-2567

  Billing & customer service

  800-673-2465

  File a claimwith Berkshire Hathaway GUARD (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Berkshire Hathaway GUARD (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Encompass Insurance

  encompassinsurance.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claim: ask DavidMake a payment: ask David
• 

  Farmers Insurance

  farmers.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claimwith Farmers Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Farmers Insurance (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Foremost Insurance Group

  foremost.com(opens in a new tab)

  Includes Foremost auto, home, and specialty policies.

  File a claimwith Foremost Insurance Group (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Foremost Insurance Group (opens in a new tab)
• 

  GEICO Marine

  geico.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claimwith GEICO Marine (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith GEICO Marine (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Hagerty

  hagerty.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service

  888-310-8020

  File a claimwith Hagerty (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Hagerty (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Integrity Insurance

  integrityinsurance.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service

  800-422-0550

  File a claimwith Integrity Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Integrity Insurance (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Liberty Mutual

  libertymutual.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims

  800-225-2467

  File a claimwith Liberty Mutual (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Liberty Mutual (opens in a new tab)
• 

  MetLife Auto & Home

  metlife.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claim: ask DavidMake a payment: ask David
• 

  Nationwide

  nationwide.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claimwith Nationwide (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Nationwide (opens in a new tab)
• 

  North Star Mutual

  northstarmutual.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service & claims

  800-622-5230

  File a claimwith North Star Mutual (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith North Star Mutual (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Philadelphia Insurance Companies

  phly.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claimwith Philadelphia Insurance Companies (opens in a new tab)Make a payment: ask David
• 

  Progressive

  progressive.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service & claims

  800-776-4737

  File a claimwith Progressive (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Progressive (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Progressive Commercial

  progressivecommercial.com(opens in a new tab)

  Customer service & claims

  800-776-4737

  File a claimwith Progressive Commercial (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Progressive Commercial (opens in a new tab)
• 

  SECURA Insurance

  secura.net(opens in a new tab)

  Phone

  800-318-2136

  File a claimwith SECURA Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith SECURA Insurance (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Selective Insurance

  selective.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claimwith Selective Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Selective Insurance (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Stillwater Insurance Group

  stillwaterinsurance.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims & roadside

  800-220-1351

  File a claimwith Stillwater Insurance Group (opens in a new tab)Make a payment: ask David
• 

  The Hartford (AARP)

  thehartford.com(opens in a new tab)

  Includes the AARP Auto & Home Insurance Program from The Hartford. Business policyholders can pay at business.thehartford.com/expresspay.

  File a claimwith The Hartford (AARP) (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith The Hartford (AARP) (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Travelers

  travelers.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims

  800-252-4633

  File a claimwith Travelers (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Travelers (opens in a new tab)
• 

  Universal Property & Casualty

  universalproperty.com(opens in a new tab)

  File a claimwith Universal Property & Casualty (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith Universal Property & Casualty (opens in a new tab)
• 

  West Bend Insurance

  thesilverlining.com(opens in a new tab)

  Claims

  877-922-5246

  Customer service

  800-236-5002

  File a claimwith West Bend Insurance (opens in a new tab)Make a paymentwith West Bend Insurance (opens in a new tab)

Links and phone numbers go to each company's official website. Company availability varies by coverage type and eligibility. If you're not sure which company insures you, check your policy declarations page or contact David.